Bagels Elevated to Perfection
ABOUT US
Welcome to Better on a Bagel, Port Jefferson Station’s go-to spot for fresh bagels, hearty sandwiches, and classic American breakfast favorites. Start your day with a perfectly brewed coffee and a warm bagel, or dive into our signature omelets and stacked sandwiches. Whether you’re craving a quick snack or a satisfying meal, our menu is packed with delicious options made to order. Taste the difference—everything’s better on a bagel!
OUR BEST SELLERSCheck out our customers' favorite menu items.
Two Eggs
Bagel with Cream Cheese
BagelsBagels available in single or dozen, with choices including plain, assorted flavors, seeds, and cheese options. Selections range from cinnamon raisin to asiago.
Three EggsThree eggs cooked your way: over easy, hard, medium, scrambled, or sunny-side up.
Bagel with ButterChoice of bagel, including plain, cinnamon raisin, sesame, poppy, and various others, served with butter.
Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese
REVIEWS
See what our customers are saying.
The Bagel with Cream Cheese was delicious-soft and fresh. Best bagel place I've found in the area, the coffee was nice and hot. And my order was correct! I got the type of bagel I ordered and size of coffee I ordered. I'll be ordering breakfast from here for now on.
Shannon C
Egg salad and hungry man both tasted very good, were fresh, and portion size very good ; btw, thanks for the utensils, etc. , just a request -please don't forget the sugar packs next time, I don't usually have any
Dave W
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
What meals do you serve?
At Better on a Bagel in Port Jefferson Station, we proudly serve a wide variety of meals to satisfy any craving. Our menu features classic New York bagels with a range of cream cheeses, hearty breakfast platters with eggs, omelets, and pancakes, as well as delicious sandwiches including turkey, roast beef, pastrami, and more. Enjoy specialty creations like the Hungry Man Sandwich, Chicken Philly, and unique omelets such as the Spanish or Italian. We also offer fresh muffins, snacks, and a full selection of beverages including coffee and fountain drinks. Whether you’re looking for breakfast, lunch, or a quick snack, Better on a Bagel has something for everyone.
Do you offer delivery or takeout?
Yes, we offer both delivery and takeout options, including convenient ordering through trusted platforms like DoorDash.
Where are you located?
We are located in Port Jefferson Station, New York.
What areas do you serve?
We serve Port Jefferson Station and nearby neighborhoods including Terryville, Mount Sinai, Coram, Selden, Setauket, East Setauket, Miller Place, Centereach, Sound Beach, and Port Jefferson.
Where are your stores located?
- Address:4960 Nesconset Hwy, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776, USAPhone number:+16314735858Hours:
- Sunday05:30 AM - 02:10 PM
- Monday05:30 AM - 03:10 PM
- Tuesday05:30 AM - 03:10 PM
- Wednesday05:30 AM - 03:10 PM
- Thursday05:30 AM - 03:10 PM
- Friday05:30 AM - 03:10 PM
- Saturday05:30 AM - 03:10 PM
Contact
Address:4960 Nesconset Hwy, Port Jefferson Station, NY 11776, USA
Copyright © 2026 Better on a Bagel. All Rights Reserved